Rebecca vocabulary

1 idioms used

1 [idiom] words
help & settings
[x]
help with word

carry coals to Newcastle

help with synonyms synonyms: Crocum in Ciliciam ferre ???
help with tags tags: [idiom]

help with definition
► definition
Definition:
To do what is superfluous. As Newcastle is the great coal—field, it would be quite superfluous to carry coals thither. The French say, " Porter de I'eau a la riviere " (to carry water to the river). There are numerous Latin equivalents as, "To carry wood to the forests," " Poma Alcinoo dare " (See Alcinoo); "Noctuas Athenas ferre " (See Noctuas), "Crocum in Ciliciam ferre " (See Crocum).

A work of supererogation, Newcastle being the great seat of coals. The Latins have "Aquam mari infundere " ("To pour water into the sea"); "Sidera caelo addere" ("To add stars to the sky"); "Noctuas Athenas" ("To carry owls to Athens," which abounds in them).

E. Cobam Brewer. Brewer's Dictionary of Phrase and Fable (1894)

help with use text
► uses
Uses:
I sat back and toyed with a couple of squares of chocolate, and wondered whether bringing Cadbury's to Switzerland was the same as bringing coals to Newcastle, and decided it wasn't. Swiss chocolate has gone badly downhill since I was a lad, and nowadays is only fit for giving to aunts.

Hugh Laurie. The Gun Seller, p.252 (1996)
---
His project meanwhile was very favourably entertained by his auditors and won hearty eulogies from all though Mr Dixon of Mary’s excepted to it, asking with a finicking air did he purpose also to carry coals to Newcastle.

James Joyce. Ulysses
---
"[...] I heard you was going to the wars; but I find it was a mistake.”—“Why do you conclude so?” says Jones. “Sure, sir,” answered the barber, “you are too wise a man to carry a broken head thither; for that would be carrying coals to Newcastle.”

Henry Fielding. The History of Tom Jones, a Foundling
---
Adding a ruby ring to the blazing splendor of his costume was coals to Newcastle, but I was touched by the anxious thought behind it.

Diana Gabaldon. Outlander (1991)
---
However curious it may seem for an oil-ship to be borrowing oil on the whale-ground, and however much it may invertedly contradict the old proverb about carrying coals to Newcastle, yet sometimes such a thing really happens; and in the present case Captain Derick De Deer did indubitably conduct a lamp-feeder as Flask did declare.

Herman Melville. Moby Dick
help with search help with search